Evaluating Learning Apps for Teaching Quality, Ads and Age Fit

how to choose educational apps for kids

Worried that an app labelled “educational” is just a game with adverts? Here is how to choose educational apps for kids: check the learning aims, count the ads, and try it yourself first.

If you are weighing up more than apps, our guide on how to choose technology for your family puts this topic in context.

Item Value
Top-downloaded children’s educational apps analysed in one study 100 apps
Apps most played by preschool-age children, also analysed 24 apps
Score each app earned for each learning pillar 0-3 for each pillar
Threshold for a lower-quality app A summed score of ≤ 4
Time spent on a shared activity that UK guidance calls beneficial 10 minutes
Children ages eight and under living in a home with a mobile device 98%

The figures come from the Department for Education’s parent guidance on early years apps (updated 4 November 2019) and an app store content analysis in the Journal of Children and Media. Figures can change, so check the sources before you rely on them.

Why the educational label is not enough

An app store category is not a quality test. In its 4 November 2019 update, the Department for Education’s parent guidance says many apps are labelled educational, but parents need to check, because quality and content vary.

The guidance questions are based on criteria the department used to identify high-quality apps for young children. They also reflect findings from many research studies on what works best in early learning apps, according to the same page. It applies to England and focuses on young children, but the questions are useful for any family.

Screens are already part of daily life. Researchers cited in the content analysis report that about 98% of children ages eight and under live in a home with a mobile device. They also report that these children spend an average of over two hours daily on screen media.

What research found when it scored popular apps

A team of researchers set out to test the educational claims of popular apps. They analysed 100 children’s educational apps with the highest downloads from Google Play and Apple app stores, plus 24 apps most frequently played by preschool-age children in a cohort study, as described in the published paper.

Each app was judged against the Four Pillars of Learning, as listed in the study abstract:

  • Active learning
  • Engagement in the learning process
  • Meaningful learning
  • Social interaction

Every app earned a value of 0-3 for each pillar, and the authors defined lower-quality apps as those scoring ≤ 4 when the pillars were summed. Their headline result was blunt: overall scores were low across all pillars, as the paper reports.

Price mattered in one specific way. Free apps scored significantly lower on engagement in the learning process, and lower overall, than paid apps, due to the presence of distracting enhancements, according to the same study. A price tag alone still does not prove an app teaches well.

how to choose educational apps for kids Shared phone use
An adult and a child look together at a smartphone held in front of them.

Questions that test an app’s teaching quality

The government guidance groups its questions under headings such as how educational the app is and what support it gives. Here are the ones that matter most for judging teaching quality, drawn from the guidance:

  1. Are the educational aims of the app clear?
  2. Are the activities structured so that you can see how your child is building on things they already know?
  3. Does the app provide support for children when they get stuck, such as prompts on screen or voice-over?
  4. Does it give helpful feedback, such as letting a child know when they are doing well or need another go?
  5. Has it been tested in academic research, or had input from an educational expert, if you can find out?
  6. Does it give feedback to an adult or older helper so they can support your child’s learning?

Gaps in these areas are common. A content analysis of maths and literacy apps for preschoolers, discussed in the same paper, noted a lack of scaffolded challenges, meaning activities that step up in difficulty as a child improves.

How do you spot ads, rewards and data collection?

Advertising can crowd out learning. The research paper points to an earlier analysis of top-downloaded apps for young children, which found that many contained disruptive video advertisements or persuaded children to watch ads in exchange for rewards.

The government guidance suggests asking whether any in-app adverts or links to the internet sit behind a parental gate, for example with a hard maths sum. Its design checklist, in the same document, adds a few more checks:

  • Does the app make it clear how your or your child’s data is being collected and used?
  • Does it let parents adjust the settings?
  • Is it free from stereotypes, for example around gender, race and disability?

Data questions go further than one app, so our guide on how to protect children’s privacy online covers the wider steps.

Matching an app to your child’s age and stage

The research raises a fit problem as well as a quality problem. Another content analysis described in the paper found that app design features failed to match normative developmental capabilities for preschool-age users.

Watch how your own child copes. The guidance suggests these signs of a good fit:

  • The child can navigate the app on their own, which aids learning.
  • There is a clear menu or home button.
  • Activities get harder the more they play.

Fit also changes as children grow, and so does the pull of a device of their own. If that question is coming up, our guide on what age should a child get a phone can help you plan.

Using apps together and setting time limits

Try the app before your child does. The government guidance advises spending time with a new download yourself first, so you can become familiar with it and help if your child struggles.

For young children, learning is best supported through interaction with adults, so the same guidance encourages using apps with them. Even just 10 minutes of doing an activity together is beneficial, and so is talking about what they are playing or learning.

On time, the guidance says there is no simple answer. It advises limiting time on apps of limited quality or repetitive in nature, while young children should still have a varied diet of activities every day, including physical activity.

Frequently asked questions

Are free apps worse than paid ones?

Show answer

Not in every case, but the evidence leans that way on one measure. In the app store study, free apps scored lower for engagement in learning because distracting extras got in the way. Check each app on its own merits rather than by price.

How long should my child use an app?

Show answer

There is no single number. The Department for Education guidance says each child and each context is different, so look at the quality of the app and the rest of your child’s day.

What if I cannot play along with my child?

Show answer

Talk about the app at another time. According to the guidance, a later chat about what they played helps and shows you care about their learning.

What is a parental gate?

Show answer

It is a barrier that stops a child tapping through to adverts or web links, for example by asking a hard maths sum. The government checklist recommends looking for one in any app your child uses.